The 2000s were an exciting time for movies. Hollywood was thriving with new franchises likeTransformers,Pirates of the Caribbean, and the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Today, cinephiles are embracing cult classics likeEternal Sunshine of the Spotless MindandJennifer’s Bodyfrom that era. However, there are also films that ended up nowhere despite their qualities and charm. These movies may have enjoyed modest success or even suffered at the hands of critics, but they have big, bold ideas that should be explored that went ot waste when they, unfortunately, ended up slipping through the cracks.
We take a look at ten of thoseunderrated gems from the 2000s that have surprisingly not endured as cult classics. These films didn’t get the love they deserved upon release, but absolutely should’ve become cult classics by now. Whether it’s because of their unique storytelling or striking visuals, each of these cinematic efforts has something that sets it apart. Some even star some of the biggest stars we have working today, so there’s no excuse not to revisit and make them your new obsessions.
10‘The Girl Next Door’ (2004)
Directed by Luke Greenfield
InThe Girl Next Door, high school senior Matthew Kidman (Emile Hirsch) is a typical nerdy overachiever with minimal social life. But everything changes when Danielle (Elisha Cuthbert), a beautiful and mysterious new neighbor, moves in next door. Encouraged by his friends to finally take some risks, Matthew starts a whirlwind romance with her, only to discover she’s a former adult film actress trying to escape her past.
On the surface,The Girl Next Doorseems like another early-2000sraunchy teen comedy. But as the film progresses, it turns into asurprisingly layered story about identity and love. It’s a high-wire act balancing fun comedy and drama. The performances are excellent, Emile Hirsch is convincing as the awkward boy, and Elisha Cuthbert makes the film her own with a layered, honest performance that subvertsthe manic pixie dream girl trope.Timothy Olyphantalso steals scenes as a sleazy, menacing producer who makes the film unpredictable. It sure has its flaws, like the overtly masculine tone and a stereotypical view of the porn industry, but it stillfeels smarter than most comedies released today.
The Girl Next Door
9‘Timecrimes’ (2007)
Directed by Nacho Vigalondo
InTimecrimes, a middle-aged man named Hector (Karra Elejalde) accidentally stumbles into a time loop while trying to investigate a strange figure in the woods. He is attacked by a mysterious figure wrapped in bloody bandages, and when he flees for help, he takes shelter in a nearby research facility. But when he emerges, he realizes that he’s traveled back in time by about an hour. He tries to fix things, but as usual with time travel, nothing is as simple as it seems.
Timecrimesisone of the most cleverly constructed time-travel thrillersof its era, and yet it remainscriminally underseen. It doesn’t rely on high-concept technology or flashy effects, but it leans into minimalist storytelling and airtight logic to build suspense. What makes it cult-classic material is its relentless tension and moral ambiguity, as Hector is both victim and villain. Each act he does to manipulate events is as disturbing as it is fascinating. DirectorNacho Vigalondocrafts a sci-fi film that feels like a puzzle box with pieces that keep moving as it goes deeper. With a low budget and great lead performance, it’sthe kind of movie that should have been everyone’s obsession.
Timecrimes
8‘The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford’ (2007)
Directed by Andrew Dominik
The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Fordchronicles the final months of the life of Jesse James, the infamous bandit and folk hero played byBrad Pitt. As the James gang dwindles and Jesse grows increasingly paranoid, a wide-eyed admirer named Robert Ford (Casey Affleck), who has idolized Jesse since childhood, joins his crew. As Jesse becomes more erratic and dangerous, Robert sees an opportunity to cement his legacy by betraying the man he once revered.
This film is not one with horse-riding and gun duels, but it’sa meditative, slow-burn Western that thrives on psychological tension. The mouthful title may be a turn-off for casual audiences, and probably an SEO nightmare for streaming services, which added more to several reasons why it hasn’t found a cult following. The film is most famous forRoger Deakins' jaw-dropping cinematography, often cited as his best work. The performances by Brad Pitt and Casey Affleck stand out, with the latter being nominated for an Oscar. This is a film that wasnever meant to please mass audiences, but at least for cinephiles and those who connect with it, it’s an unforgettable and rich experience, unlike anything else from its era.
The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford
7‘Stay’ (2005)
Directed by Marc Forster
Stayfollows psychiatrist Sam Foster (Ewan McGregor) as he begins treating a troubled young art student named Henry Letham (Ryan Gosling), who announces his plan to commit suicide on his upcoming 21st birthday. As Sam attempts to uncover the reasons behind his disturbing behavior, reality begins to distort, and Sam’s journey to save Henry becomes increasingly surreal, blurring the lines between dream and memory.
Staywas, unfortunately, dismissed upon its release andcriticized for being confusing or overly stylized, but that’s exactly what makes it so compelling. This film evokes the same feeling as watchingDonnie DarkoandMulholland Drive, exploring trauma and the subconscious. Ewan McGregor and Ryan Gosling give strong, understated performances that ground the film, while Marc Forster’s (Finding Neverland) direction leans into the dreamlike atmosphere with clever transitions and haunting imagery. It hasone of the most shocking endingsthat, for sure, would take over social media if it were released today. With Gosling becoming more popular than ever,this mind-bending film deserves a devoted fan base.
6‘Brick’ (2005)
Directed by Rian Johnson
InBrick,Rian Johnsoncreated a noir detective story in an unlikely setting of a modern Southern California high school. The film follows Brendan Frye (Joseph Gordon-Levitt), who goes deep into the underworld of his school to investigate the mysterious death of his ex-girlfriend, Emily (Emilie de Ravin). Brendan scours through a maze of cryptic messages and shady characters, uncovering a web of deception within the school to get closer to the truth.
Brickis Rian Johnson’s debut feature, and he is already very confident in his vision. With such a singular voice, it’s no surprise that Johnson went on to direct big movies such asStar Wars: The Last JediandKnives Out. Borrowing a lot from noir films,the dialogue is stylized, dense with slang, fast-talking rhythm, and some plot progression may not be the usual high school drama, but that’s why it’s so unique.Bricknever tries to be quirky or ironic, but it plays it straight for the audience. It’sone of the most original and sharply executed takes on high school and noiralike. It’s clever, moody, and endlessly rewatchable.
5‘The Fountain’ (2006)
Directed by Darren Aronofsky
The Fountaintells three parallel stories across a thousand years, all connected by a man’s (Hugh Jackman) desperate quest to save the woman (Rachel Weisz) he loves. In one timeline, set in 16th-century Spain, a conquistador named Tomás searches for the legendary Tree of Life to save Queen Isabella from death. In the present day, Tommy Creo is a scientist racing against time to find a cure for his wife Izzi’s terminal brain tumor. And in a distant future, a space traveler named Tom floats through the cosmos in a biosphere, accompanied only by a dying tree, seemingly seeking transcendence.
Initially misunderstood and critically divided, thisarthouse romance adventurehas since emerged as a deeply personal and spiritually ambitious film that defies easy categorization. It’s not a traditional sci-fi or romance, but a genre-blending experiment that’s more interested in emotional truth than linear storytelling. Hugh Jackman sheds his tough Wolverine persona to deliver one of his most vulnerable performances, while Rachel Weisz brings grace to the women his characters love asthe heart of the interlinked stories.The Fountainis precisely the kind ofdaring, polarizing film that grows in resonance over timeand should find a bigger cult following.
The Fountain
4‘Torque’ (2004)
Directed by Joseph Kahn
Torquefollows Cary Ford (Martin Henderson), a biker who’s looking to clear his name after being framed for a crime he didn’t commit. His problems get worse when the leader of the Hellions gang, Henry James (Matt Schulze), frames a murder on Ford, sparking a massive turf war. Ford races to stay alive while trying to win back his girlfriend and take down James' gang and corrupt FBI agents.
It was easy to dismiss this at the time of its release asFast & Furiouson bikes, but it could not be more different.Directed byJoseph Kahn, who’s a renowned music video director who has worked withTaylor Swift,Britney Spears,and theBackstreet Boys, the film isa highly stylized action excess.Kahn employed his music video skills and implemented them in this movie, and the result is a slick fever dream of a film that is self-aware and glorious. TheVin Diesel-led franchise may have started doingimpossible stuntsby the fifth movie, butTorquedid it in its only movie. It was maybe too weird to be appreciated in its time, butTorquehasall the ingredients for cult classic glory.
3‘Drag Me to Hell’ (2009)
Directed by Sam Raimi
Drag Me to Hellcenters on Christine Brown (Alison Lohman), an ambitious loan officer at a Los Angeles bank who’s eager for a promotion. To prove she can make tough decisions, she denies an extension on an elderly woman’s mortgage, even after the woman begs on her knees. Unfortunately for Christine, the woman turns out to be a Romani sorceress who places a terrifying curse on her. Christine is then tormented by the demonic Lamia, who will drag her to hell in three days.
Sam Raimi’s return to horror after hisSpider-Mantrilogy is a masterclass, improving on his gleefully grotesque and scaryEvil Deadseries.Drag Me To Hellis bold, over-the-top, and completely committed. Raimi’s trademark mix of slapstick horror and energetic camerawork is full on display. However, after its release, the film never found the same love as his classic horror series starringBruce Campbell. With no shortage of iconic scenes, includingits memorable ending, the filmshould be endlessly quoted and screened annually. It’s Raimi in his wheelhouse and at his most unfiltered.
Drag Me To Hell
2‘The Fall’ (2006)
Directed by Tarsem Singh
Set in a 1920s LA hospital,The Fallfollows the story of Roy Walker (Lee Pace), a paralyzed stuntman who weaves a fantastical epic for Alexandria (Catinca Untaru), a young immigrant girl recovering from a broken arm. His story follows five mythical heroes, including a masked bandit (also played by Pace), on a quest for revenge against an evil emperor.
The Fallisa visual feast. Shot in over 20 countries with little to no CGI, every frame feels like a painting, drenched in rich color and surreal imagery. But beyond the spectacle, it is anemotionally resonant film that rewards its viewers. The film explores storytelling as a means of salvation, using fantasy to connect and to heal.The Fallis one of Pace’s earliest roles, and it’s obvious that his star power emanates through the screen, leading him to bigger roles in big franchises like the MCU andThe Hobbit. DirectorTarsem Singhpours his entire creative vision into the project, resulting in a film that’s as intimate as it is operatic.The Fallneeds to be appreciated more, and each frame of the film is turned into a work of art.
1‘Sunshine’ (2007)
Directed by Danny Boyle
Set in a near future where the sun is dying,Sunshinefollows the multinational crew of the Icarus II, a spacecraft carrying a massive nuclear payload intended to reignite the dying star. The mission is humanity’s last hope for survival. As the crew approaches the sun, they receive a distress signal from Icarus I, the failed first mission that vanished seven years earlier. They divert course to investigate, only to trigger a series of catastrophic events.
Despite its high-concept premise, impressive visuals, and a star-studded ensemble cast, thisDanny Boylefilm didn’t receive the recognition it deserved. Part2001: A Space Odyssey, partAlien, andpart slasher horror, the film is a hard sci-fi film until it pivots in the third act. That tonal shift may turn off some viewers, but for its fans, it’s what made it iconic. The stacked cast includesCillian Murphy,Rose Byrne,Chris Evans,Michelle Yeoh, andHiroyuki Sanada, all delivering performances that strengthen the film’s bold ideas. It’s anambitious, flawed, yet unforgettable filmthat cult classics are made of.
NEXT:You Probably Haven’t Seen These 10 Action Movies From the 2000s — You Should
